People love Escobar defensively because he makes routine plays look great, while Hardy makes great plays look routine. Hardy, at this point, is the better defender. That's not fair. People love Escobar because he has the athletic gifts to blossom into one of the great defensive shortstops in the game. While Hardy is the better defender right now, his potential is fulfilled. Escobar absolutely looks like he will become a better defender than J.J. Hardy certainly has excellent hands & a strong, accurate arm, along with reading the ball well off the bat. However, much of his success on defense is also due to good positioning by the coaching staff -- although I will admit J.J. may well be responsible for some of that, too.