Who is arguing with the return on his contract? I said was he was a solid player. Talking to a guy and telling him he is fantastic has nothing to do with how well he actually performs. A .367 wOBA to a .346 wOBA is a difference of about one win over a full season. I consider that significant. An average MLB wOBA is around .335 I believe(I think Tango said .340 if you look it up but that was a while ago). I am not sure how you can say a guy who is a little over average is "fantastic." Fielder, Braun and Weeks are fantastic. McGehee is a solid MLB player