"The rules" applied to Hall as well, but he was asked to go down twice, and accepted on the second ask even though he didn't have to. I'm sure a class act like Suppan wouldn't object to going down to Nashville to make himself better, would he? Hall has stunk for almost 3 years now. JJ only had one bad year. The situations are not comparable at all. In fact, they sent JJ down much quicker than Hall. It really doesn't sound like they have made up their mind on Escobar either. Sounds like better than 50/50 odds JJ is the starter from the outset next year.