I don't think he is as bad as people make him out to be. He really is. He hasn't had a positive UZR/150 since 2003. His best in that time is a -4.1UZR/150.(-9.6, -6.3, -15.2, -4.1, -23.1)Link 2006-2008 Plus/minus has him ahead of only Dye, Hawpe and Cuddyer. Link IMO he just doesn't have the offensive tool set that this team really needs and his skill set the team may have enough of at times. Doesn't matter how he gets his offensive value. You may not like it, it may not be pretty, but it really doesn't matter.