I don't think this is a good deal... I think hall is suffering from some backlash around here right now, and i think it's because he was so popular over the summer. the truth is that he's a better player than those other guys. He easily has more power than both Baldelli and Ensberg, and while ensberg walks alot and Baldelli hits for a good average, Hall is trending upward, and will likely post a better OBP than both of those guys next year. Obviously, Hall is younger than Ensberg and he hasn't had the injury issues that baldelli has had. On top of that, hall is a brewer for 3 more years---through his prime---and he shouldnt cost more than 20 million in that period. As for Turnbow and Lidge---i could care less. Does it really matter which of these guys we have? Lidge is likely better, but he costs more and there is no guarantee that he'll be better than last year. Trading Villenueva at this moment seems like a short sighted idea. Just because the Brewers have 5 starters under contract ahead of him does not mean he is expendable. Perhaps next offseason, but as it stands now, he is the 6th starter. I think you are overvaluing Ensberg and drastically undervaluing Hall. Baldelli is interesting, but he's quite the risk. If the Brewers are going to contend in the next 3 years (and they should in all three), then Hall needs to be part of the team.