I think most baseball fans don't like their team's manager. Unless they're winning of course. My Red Sox fan friend thinks Francona is at least 50% bonehead. Torre was run out 2 or 3 jobs until he landed with the stacked Yankees team. Now he a beloved cuddly bear, who many consider a great manager. In other sports, particularly football, the head coach may be the most important person in the organization. More important than the talent on the field. In baseball, this simply isn't true with managers. If players perform, the manager is brilliant; sometimes even "innovative". If the players fail, the manager is run out of town on a rail. I think this is why managers are too scared to think outside the box. They all do pretty much the same thing, so when it fails, they can say "we had our guy in there, he just didn't get it done". That said, I don't hate Macha and I think he's smarter than Yost. Yost was good when the team was bad, but as the team improved he couldn't seem to handle the pressure. I don't mind that Macha is rather emotionless on the bench; almost all managers are that way. I do have a hard time figuring out what made Melvin hire him. They don't seem to be on the same page, like he and Yost were in the early days.