Yes, by all means let's look at the career minor leaguers who got away and four years later turned into good ballplayers for a couple seasons. But lets ignore the similar players that Melvin acquired who had similar career paths: McGehee, Turnbow, Pods, Clark, etc. I think the trade for CC came after JDLR, didn't it? Randy Wolf was considered the second best free agent pitcher on the market last winter and the smallest market in baseball was able to sign this die hard Californian to a Midwestern team. Please cite examples of teams who did trade for top of the rotation starters under similar payroll restrictions. I can think of two trades, Garza and Kazmir that may qualify. Would you have supported trading the talent it would take to get these players? And four years later, when/if those players had good seasons with other teams would you still be satisfied or would you want Melvin fired for letting that talent go?