You're making sense there, MJLive. Let me add I think some players' chances are hurt by playing in the steroid era. Fred McGriff hit 500+ homers, had a very similar career to my favorite player of all time, Eddie Murray, but will probably not get in. Most seem to think the Crime Dog was good, but not great when compared to his contemporaries. But his contemporaries may have artificially high numbers due their drug use. So if they get in it means cheaters win, while guys like McGriff who may have been on the straight and narrow, end up losing.