I realize Braun is the "franchise" pplayer, but given the offense Hardy has put up this year while playing ss, I think it's fair to call him the either the best player or the MVP of the team , as far as position players go. That's certainly a viable option. I just think few teams will make defensive shifts unless a player's is defense is so poor it's costing lots of wins. I just think when a team is playoff caliber they tend to make moves that are less risky. Moving your All Star caliber ss to 3rd and handing the starting ss job to a AA rookie is the sort of thing a rebuilding team does. Keeping your ss where he is and trying to upgrade 3B with a "proven" veteran is something a competitive team is more likely to do. That's certainly possible, especially if Escobar plays like an All Star in AAA next year. At that point trading Weeks or Hardy could be the better move. My point is, if Hardy is signed on for 3-4 more years you may get the most value for next year by trading Escobar as part of a deal for quality starting pitcher or 3B. In the end I guess it depends on if you think the Brewers should build on this year's success, re-tool, and go for it again in 2009 with largely the same team, or if they should take a step back in 2009 and risk a minor rebuild with the hope for a stronger team in 2010. I think most teams will continue to "go for it" each year, until it's clear a current core group has peaked.