Yes, I realize that the Win/Loss record isn't relavant in grading a pitcher's year, and your disclaimer "When he's been healthy" isn't really a disclaimer because health is always a factor in determining whether a pitcher is having a down year, but I guess if you want to put it in your terms which in my opinion doesn't tell the real story, then to each is own. Also, Thank you, JimH5 for breaking it down game by game for Sheets. It's hard evidence that Sheets is having an on par year under my parameters, not Russ's.