McGehee was raking at at third base, and I wonder if his knee limited him to staying at third base. If I remember correctly, Hall was tried at second base and he wasn't very good there. And what makes you think Hardy would have accepted being moved to second? If the rumors are true that he scoffed at moving to third for Escobar, I don't see why he would have been suddenly willing to move to second. As far as Counsell is concerned, from the time Weeks went down with an injury on May 17 to the time the Brewers acquired Lopez on July 19, the Brewers played 55 games (If I counted correctly). Out of those 55 games, Counsell played in 48. In 39 of those 48 games, Counsell played second base. During that time span he went from a .339/.432 avg/obp to a .280/.350 avg/obp. Now I realize that he wasn't going to maintain a .339 average or a .432 obp. and I will concede that his .280/.350 line was also respectable/good. But Counsell, at his age, isn't really capable of playing every day at this point in his career. I would imagine Melvin and Co. noticed the decline in Counsell's numbers and the lack of productive options they really had, and went ahead and traded for Lopez. I won't consider that a poor move, or a sign that they didn't have a plan. I think you could argue that the Brewers didn't acquire Lopez soon enough.