Not much difference between them. Buxton's career: 6.7% BB, 31.6% K, wOBA .294, wRC+ 79 Broxton's career: 10.7% BB, 37.2% K, wOBA .312, wRC+ 93 You could make an argument that Broxton is a better player offensively. I haven't seen much of Buxton defensively, but to be a 3.5 fWAR player last year he must be the best thing in CF since Willie Mays.