No, but people are insisting that both are terrible at hitting by choosing periods of AB's where they were not 100%, i.e. the Move Weeks Down in the order thread, even though when 100% healthy, they've been pretty damn good. And for some reason that is to be completely disregarded. Sure, that doesn't make up for how awful they've been so far this year. But when using small(ish) samples, players are wildly inconsistent. If they started out hot and this month and a half lull occured in July and August, it would probably go largely unnoticed, just like JJ's did to the casual fan last year.