While I'm surprised, I'm not fully disappointed. What I know about Leonhard is that he is the epitome of what it means to be a Badger. Work your ass off and be loyal to your team. Unfortunately, that doesn't always equate to being a good head coach. We don't know what he would have done. Was Wisconsin football ready to roll the dice with him? I guess not.
With that said, Fickell is 49. I think this is going to be his destination unless there is something HUGE that comes to pass. Is OSU going to fire Ryan Day? No. If they do, then Ryan Day can come coach at Wisconsin.
Some random points:
Barry Alvarez was from outside the program. He was a product of Nebraska, Iowa, and Notre Dame. He also had the opportunity to leave for Miami, Fla. and didn't (although he was playing Donna Shalala for more money).
I believe that Fickell will stay true to the Badger culture. It probably isn't much different than that at Ohio State -- except the booster and NIL money at OSU is much, much different.
Sorry, but when people say that Wisconsin has always been a second-tier program, I have to disagree. They have been to 20-straight bowl games. They were one or two spots away from a BCS bid. Are they at the level of OSU, Alabama, Clemson? No way. Up until this year... and last year, they were very competitive.
Remember, Paul Chryst didn't set things ablaze when he coached at Pitt. He was a very good offensive coordinator and I think he was not able to be as successful fulfilling the responsibilities of being a head coach. I have a feeling the same might be said for Jim Leonhard -- good defensive coordinator, but not as good of a head coach. We don't know, and it would probably be better if he got his feet wet somewhere else.
How is Dave Aranda doing? He even left for LSU and is the head coach at Baylor. Being a good DC or OC doesn't necessarily mean that person will be a good HC.
I saw either Tom Oates or Jeff Potrykus mention that the Badgers had two of their best recruiting classes ever and that recruiting wasn't a problem. Really? No evidence for that. Those journalists are too close to the program to think objectively.
Fickell stayed on at OSU after he was the interim head coach and Urban Meyer was hired. Are we sure that Leonhard is going to leave? Everyone thinks he is gone. Of course, they all thought he was going to be the HC. Leonhard might just stay on board.
Brad Soderberg all over again?
Some have already decommitted. It seems like the ledge is getting very crowded and people are already jumping off. The next few weeks will be interesting for sure.