Several points 1. McLane (and that's the spelling) is a meddlesome owner. Not as bad as some, and he's generally put a good product on the field. Before this season the Astros had the 4th best winning percentage in baseball since 1992. 2. The decision to play Biggio so much came from McLane. 3. The farm system is depleted because of 10 years of bad drafts. 4. The Jennings trade was an act of desperation after Pettitte went to NYC. I didn't think it was a bad trade at the time, but apparently the Astros allowed the Rockies to snooker them on Jennings' health. Jennings pitched at Baylor and McLane is a Baylor alum. 5. Garner platoons way too much. 6. The Astros have about 45 mil a year wrapped up in just 3 players. McLane is not a cheap owner, but he's not going to go out and mimic the Yankees or the Red Sox. With a barren farm system, getting cheap talent is going to be difficult and having so much salary invested in 3 players is gonna make it difficult for the next GM to get talent. Bottom line - while neither Purpura or Garner did a good job, it's hard to figure out how much flexibility McLane gave them.