I really can't believe there is any discussion here. Counsell has a below replacement level bat for a short stop at this point. He is pretty much the embodiment of a replacement level player at 37, I mean we are talking about a guy who only hit decent for three seasons. Branyan's VORP is 10.6 as a 3B, Counsel's is -2.1 as a SS. If Counsell is now taking over at 3B we are talking almost 2 wins of difference over 2 months assuming about 100 PAs in a month.