Obviously that's bad, but I'm saying that he has had many more good games than bad. He has just been really, really bad when he's been off. If you take out his three terrible, horrible, awful games - the one at New York, the Cubs debacle, and the Orioles game - his WHIP drops to better than the NL average (if I did the math correctly, not counting tonight). I know that those games count just like his good ones, but my point is that he has given the team a chance to win in most of his starts. Just a few games can blow stats out of whack. I'm not saying he's an All Star or "worth" his salary, but overall, he has done a decent job this year. You're forgetting the Washignton game where he gave up 5 unearned runs in one inning. Most major league pitchers aren't going to crap out every single time, they are too good for that. But all have really bad starts, the really good ones might have 2 a season, the bad ones like 8 to 10.