Given the years and amount I think this should work out pretty well for the Crew. If Lucroy happens to have a 20 HR season or hit .300 at some point then it becomes a steal, just due to the inflated arbitration price that would bring. With the rather good amount of pitch framing skill, I think that puts LuCroy in the the top 1/2 to 1/3 of catchers. My concern methodologically, is that we seem to be finally making some progress more accurately measuring catcher defense (which seemed like the ultimate black hole of measurements back in the early Brewerfan days). The thing is that there are so many distinct catcher skills, framing, game calling, throwing, and blocking that looking at just one and pronouncing him a well above average defensive catcher is not the best approach. In rushing through some of that it seemed like he was middle of the road to slightly below average in some of the other skills. His framing is so good I'm sure he is an overall net plus with the glove, but it may not be as dramatic looking when all of the defensive skills are tallied in. Still there is a fair amount of value in having a guy who is solid across the board and one who might still improve noticeably in a few areas.