Allow me to interject a little humor here, reading MLBTR, a Giants fan proposed the following trade. Bumgarner for, get ready, Keston Hiura, Corbin Burnes, Domingo Santana, and Corey Ray. Then goes on to state that "It’s not an overwhelming asking price for a pitcher like Bumgarner"! The Brown/Stokes package mentioned earlier would be OK for me, but the Giants are going to ask for Burnes, Woodruff or Peralta. For me, Burnes is off the table. Woodruff has really impressed me when given the chance to, again I would be reluctant to give him up for one year of MB. Leaving us Peralta, the young man has electric stuff, yes he was inconsistant, needs more development and polishing, but he has shown he deserves to be here. Starting material? IDK, but Peralta would be a devastating bookend to Hader at the least. Peralta for 1 year of Bumgarner? NO!! 2 years maybe, but we have waited years to be able to develop pitching in the system hanging our hopes on the Golds, Neaugebauers, and Hendricksons only to be left disappointed. Now we have 3! Each one has shown to be able to get outs at the major league level and now we are considering trading one for single year of a MB? I agree with jerichoholicninja, his velocity is down and he has a lot of wear on that arm. Just not worth it. Brown and Stokes is the max I would go.