I agree with that. If all the other variables are equal (talent, age, performance, injury history, etc.), then you could use something like your interpretation of "heart" to determine who you would prefer to acquire. When all things aren't equal, like normal, you need to take the guy who is a better player when measured conventionally with statistics. For every Bonds and Sheffield in the hall there will be a Jeter and Schilling. Schilling is often considered selfish and a drama queen, and a lot of his teammates don't like him. Boston doesn't care because he's good. I thought players played the game to win titles, not make the Hall. Show me one player who singlehandedly won a title. There isn't one. All players need talented players surrounding them.