If he were a legit HOF'er, it wouldn't be so close. He just isn't good enough. I don't really think Power/Speed is that useful, either. Do you honestly think he's as good as some of the guys he's ahead of in that category? For me, it's a simple "no". If he were really a great, feared hitter, then why didn't he ever walk (the most he walked in a season was 44 times)? If he gets in, it sets the bar even lower for the Hall, and it's too low already.