We have very different opinions on this. If he were out there churning away talking about his innocence every chance he got, I'd assume he was guilty. We don't know what happened, we aren't going to know what happened until maybe after he retires. He is not allowed to give more info and the arbiter is not allowed to give more info and MLB either can't talk about it or isn't giving more info. We have nothing but shady statements on BOTH sides about what happened. We have next to no info on how any of this went down from any source. So you are basically going to be left to your own devices on whether you are going to believe him, not believe him or take what I think is the most reasonable stance and that is... I don't know what happened.