I've tossed this around in my mind for a long time, but I think today I've come to my own conclusion (and I'm going to post this as if my opinion is really important). The Brewers absolutely 100% need to trade Prince Fielder this July. I have an extremely hard time believing that Scott Boras will make one of his biggest clients an exception to his rule: The only chance the Brewers have of re-signing Fielder will be in free agency. That does not bode well for the Brewers. Even if Prince does re-sign, it will be massive and the team will have limited flexibility long-term. Yes, it will be a relief to have some of the big Suppan/Hall contracts off the books, but there are several other important players on the team due pay raises. If the impact arms (Rivas, Arnett, perhaps Rogers or Jeffress) we expect to blossom into top-of-the-rotation MLB starters don't pan out as quickly as we thought, the Brewers will remain stuck plugging holes in the back end of the rotation, relying on Gallardo and Wolf to be 1 and 2 - not altogether enticing. I think we've seen that the Brewers' potential is capped with the caliber of pitching they have, despite Fielder performing at the level he's at right now. This really has nothing to do with Prince himself, which is what hurts the most about it; he's exactly the kind of special player that a team can build around. It's just not responsible for a small-market team like the Brewers to make a long-term investment at this price on ANY player, much less Prince - who will always have questions concerning his weight and durability long-term. As tired as that argument is, it's something that has to be considered. It's amazing how many players nowadays on the tail end of massive contracts are financially killing their teams, and the fans turn on them because of it. It just seems as if every big long-term contract ends ugly. Not to mention that trading Fielder rather than simply losing him is preferable because the Brewers control his destination, at least in the short term. I don't want to hear about the Cubs and Yankees bidding for his service, if at all possible. And it's not like the Brewers will be getting A-ballers in return. They can get major league ready (or at least very near major league ready) arms and bats for someone as coveted as Fielder. It's not really a rebuilding move, in my mind - the Brewers can still have a potent offense built around Braun, Weeks, McGehee, Gamel, and Escobar, and whoever comes over in the trade. Obviously not as potent - Fielder isn't replaceable - but improved pitching in both quantity and quality will go a long way at evening it out. Depending on the return, of course, I think the Brewers could absolutely content in 2011 and years beyond. Now if they're 20 games over .500 at the deadline, leave it alone. But I don't think that's being realistic. It'll be truly painful to have to trade away one of the organization's brightest and most successful home-grown stars, especially considering the relationship Fielder has created with the fans. But I think it has to be done.