Before 2021 Riley was only a .240/.300/.450 hitter in the Majors. If that qualifies as an impact bat then so did Urias, Garcia, Adames and Narvaez. There were 4 players that by your definition would be big bats. You may want to look at the stats before making these claims and not just looking at the names of the players. Albies even in 2021 was only a .259/.310/.488 hitter which would put him in the same category as Adames and Narvaez.
Your arguments have no points because I think you are just pulling things from thin air and not looking at anything to back up what you are saying. The only player historically that was good that you named was Freeman.
Castellanos career wise is .279/.330/.487 which would put him as the 2nd best bat for the Brewers but Adames and Narvaez are also close to Castellanos career wise with .260/.330/.439 and .266/.351/.398. Adames and Narvaez are really close to Castellanos. Again Castellanos is not in the MVP category for a hitter. He is a good hitter but he is not in the category of MVP type of a player who is going to carry a team for weeks at a time.