Again, based on what? One fantastic game against a dumpster fire Illinois program? Every other game he's literally looked like Alex Hornibrook. At some point, you can't blame the game plan for missing mid-level throws. If you can't hit the throws, arm strength doesn't matter. Hornibrook couldn't hit mid-level plus passes, and neither can Mertz. One may have been due to arm strength, the other is due to inaccuracy and decision making, which may actually be worse. In the end, they're both guys who can hit 5-yard passes and not be trusted on much else, and turn the ball over at an absurd rate. The reality is, Jack Coan should be the Badgers' QB this year, and they made the wrong choice. Mertz may be very good eventually, but he's just a guy now. It isn't just the Illinois game which was more of a NFL style defense and Illinois played him very well actually there were a bunch of deep throws that should have been knocked down that weren't. Then the play calling went ultra conservative after the Michigan game with very few deep balls thrown. How many deep balls were thrown in this game? I don't think there was a single 10+ yard throw all game and I don't think there was a single route that was ran that was more than 10-yards. Majority of the throws were 5-yard throws where the defense could just sit back and camp the routes. I am not sure why you are so hesitant to blame the scheme. If you keep running the same routes over and over again it is not going to matter what the QB does. The defense is going to react and adjust which the Penn State defense did while on the offensive there were no changes. The cornerbacks weren't even playing press coverage during the 2nd half. If the Badgers wanted to they had plenty of opportunities to go for a deep ball but never did. Everything was between 5 - 10 yard routes and nothing over 10 yards. At some point no matter what you think about your QB and their accuracy you have to go and take a shot otherwise the defense is just going to sit on those short passes which is what Penn State did. This is all scheme based Coan wouldn't have done any better than what Mertz did. Maybe instead of a fumble the Badgers are able to get a FG on one of the drives. But there is absolutely no evidence that Coan would have done better. Mertz problem isn't the deep balls he is actually very accurate on the deep balls compared to Hornibrook. I am not sure you are remembering exactly what Hornibrook's problem was. It was that he would float the ball and it had no zip on passes longer than 10-yards. Mertz has a lot of zip on his passes and he is actually rather accurate with the longer throws. It actually on the shorter throws where he is inaccurate. At some point you have to change the scheme a bit if your QB is struggling and Chryst just will not make the changes needed. Coan struggled a few times like this and Chryst never made any adjustments. Just look at the Ohio State games he never makes an adjustment to his game plan it is the same every single game. You would think at some point he would change something up but he hasn't. He is incapable of making a change and it is hurting the players in the process. The game plan is horrible and the scheme is horrible as Chryst is not taking advantage of the talent that he has, he is still playing like JT is the starting RB in the backfield. He refuses to make changes to his run game to help the running backs he has and he refuses to make changes to the passing game which has been stale for the last 4-years. Other than 4 games where he wasn't doing the play calling the offense has been stuck in this horrible rut where they don't run any passing plays over 10-yards. That is 100% scheme and not the QB if you don't allow the QB to throw those passes it is 100% on the scheme and not on the QB.