I don't think I ever heard Roache referred to as 'toolsy'. Dude had power - nothing more. Coulter wasn't much different - although he did have a strong arm. I was just going to post this. Clancy I don't think you understand what "toolsy" prospect means with your examples. The more "toolsy" prospects would be Arcia, Cain, Weeks, Braun, Hart, Ray, Lutz, Gray, Grisham, Ward, Lara and others. I would assume that the "toolsy" prospects flame out at about the same rate as everyone else does. You get a bigger boom out of a "toolsy" prospect than the one dimensional ones even if you don't hit on a "toolsy" prospect you still have someone who can be a utility player or a decent regular (Arcia). I prefer the "toolsy" athletic players over the "traditional baseball" player. The game is becoming more about athleticism (OF's are being graded like WR & DB in football now) than it is about the traditional baseball attributes. I don't see this changing any time soon so we should start seeing more of these athletic type of players over your traditional baseball player as they fit in better with analytics.