1) Santana for Severino - A-. Santana is an average bat at best, but elite D. Clearly an upgrade on what we had (especially with Miller faltering and Tellez injured). Didn't give up much to get there.
2) Canha for Jarvis - B. Again, an upgrade on our current RF, but again only to "average". Again didn't give up much to get there.
3) Chafin for Strezlecki - B+ interesting trade of struggling relievers. Chafin more likely helps this year. Strez more for future years or maybe we capitalized on a flash in the pan 2022?
4) Blalock for Urias - B. Hurts to give up on Urias at this point, but clearly a long-term roster focused move. Got a decent arm for someone that is probably non-tendered next year when it was unlikely to see him back up this year. Also Monestario is currently producing at Urias' career level, so there is some redundancy on the roster already. Hope the best for Urias in Boston where he gets a fresh start. In the long run, Boston may "win" this trade but it will also cost them $$ to see that additional WAR.
5) McKendry for Jackson - A+ I think this was a great grab. Still not an Earth shattering move, but pulling in a potential SP rotational depth for 2024 by giving up a catcher we didn't necessarily have plans on using is a great move. Maybe gives Jackson a better chance at the MLB level too.
Missed opportunities= Controversially... I'll say NONE. Sure, they could've done more and yes, we are risking wasting another year of our strong SP staff. But I think the improvements needed to make this squad a legit WS contender right now is pretty significant and the risk very high to "sell off the farm" to get all the bats necessary.
To me it looks like management is putting us in a situation to have a chance (slightly more than Dumb and Dumber) by getting into the playoffs and then getting hot. By getting "hot", I mean that Frelick plays well, our additions play "average", Tellez is healthy and plays his career norms, and BA and Adames bounce back to their norms while our pitching remains strong.
Overall deadline Grade= B+. They found decent improvements (i.e. plugging holes in the dike) for very low cost. They used some creativity to strengthen the future while making mild improvements to the current.