Your reading way too much into small sample numbers. Not really, I'm looking at his entire body of work: R+: 580 A: 474 A+ 459 AA: 406 AAA: 486 (420 home/ 555 away) I see a progression going the wrong direction. At 22, its quite possible that he made a jump in strength. But I think you are giving him too much credit for being 22 also. I don't think there is that much more he can increase his slugging going forward. Players obviously gain strength as they age, but he is leaving the point where there is much more development there (still some, but I think 22-23 is the "knee of the curve"). Gind has the best raw power of the group. This I seriously doubt. Schafer - yes. Green - probably not (wrist injury makes that hard to use history numbers). Gamel - not a chance. with a lightning quick bat, very good bat control, and a terrific eye. I've never heard anyone give him that much credit on bat speed, but otherwise I agree. His OBP numbers are great. The main problem comparing Gindl, Green and Schafer is that Green and Shafer play positions where there are lower offensive expectations. If all three hit 820 at their positions (Gindl in RF, Shafer in CF and Green at 3B), you: - Send Schafer to the all-star game - Congratulate Green for an excellent year at 3B. - Think about replacing Gindl in RF.