The only “miss” would be Bill Hall - 8 years with the organization.
Richie Sexson had 4 highly successful years in Milwaukee. And Lorenzo Cain was a key cog in 2018-2019, and had a bonus year with the Crew in 2010.
Also -yes catching outside of Lucroy was a black hole (one good season by Grandal, a couple by Kendall and Miller were ok, then a lot of poor seasons or guys I forgot played there before Lucroy, and since him it’s been mainly Pina, Narvaez and now Contreras in recent years)