So in football, when Clay Matthews has the QB in his sights, he should be allowed 6 steps after the QB throws the ball? The would be unnecessary roughness all day long. In baseball, the only issue is their isn't much of a precedence for punishing Utley. So if that is your argument, that's fine. I won't disagree with that. But Utley, knew exactly what he was doing when he began his slide into the mid thigh of Tejada. It wasn't a split second, oooops moment. He knew based on where the ball was, where Tejada was coming from and where he needed so "slide" to take Tejada out completely. And my gut tells me, this type of tackle slide will soon be banned. Read the Police Magazine article. Let's give Chase Utley 1.5 seconds to be generous (as I noted earlier, the Tueller Drill has the person covering 21 feet in 1.5 seconds from a standing start - if he's running at full speed, that timeframe is going to be shorter). He's lost .58 seconds as he is seeing the second baseman field the ball and flip it to Tejada. That means he's taken two of those six steps, roughly. So, Utley's already taking two steps running at full speed as he sees the second baseman field the ball and flip it to Tejada. Now, he has to decide what to do, while still running at full speed. He can't think it through, by then, he is going to run past second. He's going to revert to his training - or in this case, what's been drilled into his head by coaches going back to high school or little league. That would be "break up the double play." In the case of Clay Matthews blitzing Jay Cutler, he's still going to need time - and space to stop when Cutler throws the pass. It will take two steps for Matthews to recognize Cutler's thrown the ball, and then at least oneor two more to make the decision he needs to stop. Should they look at this play and consider a rule change? Probably. But a suspension, especially when there is no precedent for doing so, is the wrong thing to do. The problem I see with your analogy is that with the police it is, guy running towards me with weapon, pull weapon to defend myself and then actually pulling the weapon, he only has those 21 feet to do that. With Utley, his decision process starts from the second he takes off, if not earlier. He only has 2 options, ball getting through and ball getting stopped by the fielder. When he starts running hes thinking, ball gets through im going to third if the fielder stops it im sliding into second to break up the double play, because he has to know that if the fielder gets to it the only way he will be safe is if theres an error. The cop also only has the time from when the guy starts running to react, whereas Utley can extrapolate where the ball is going and see before the fielder gets the ball that he will get the ball. So he has more time to act then just when the fielder actually touches the ball. I also think the act of starting a slide is a little easier to initiate then trying to draw a gun. Therefore I think he had more than enough time to slide safer if he wanted to and purposely went high to make sure Tejada couldn't complete the throw to first, though I don't think he wanted to hurt him, just knock him down.