Kemp played in 399 straight games and then in May 2012 he went down with a "Hamstring injury" at that time he was batting: .359/.446/.726/ 1.173 12HRs in 34 games 140PAs 118ABs Since then he's accumulated 599 PAs .276/.328/.436/.764 17HRs and just 16SBs. I just don't like behind the numbers his 2011 season and start to 2012 to me stands out as not the norm. Now he has multiple injuries behind him ankle/hamstring/shoulder joint issue.... How is it a good idea to take a guy on being paid to be 2011 who was healthy then who's cressed his prime and should eventually begin his decline? He's not a defensive stalwart. Why can't we go with our own Khris Davis and cheer him on for 525k this year? I'll wager $50 now with anyone Davis hits more HRs than Kemp this year. Yeah, when you're injured, you're not as likely to put up big numbers. I realize we're going on the assumption that everyone's on roids these days, I just don't believe aside from that, you made a very compelling case. Played with Manny, and has gotten injured. Steroids usually take a long time...years of abuse before you start dealing with the soft tissue damage and joint injuries. He's missed most of his time from a shoulder and ankle IIRC. Not that rare in baseball. And I'm not going to wager 50 bucks on who hits more HR's because...It's really not that important to me. Kemp's almost certainly going to be playing in a much bigger stadium and not going to be playing everyday. Not to mention, that's really an awful way to judge which is a better player. Davis can't play anywhere else on the field but in LF because he's so limited defensively. Kemp may not be a "stalwart," but I believe he'd be pretty solid if healthy in RF, and Braun would be a big upgrade at 1st base. At the end of the day, the Brewers aren't going to add 126 million dollars over the next SIX YEARS, and even if the Dodgers were desperate to dump him, we don't have enough bad contracts to give them to make it worth it. And I'd also be worried about his long term production....but it'd certainly make 2014 more interesting. Or, Kemp just had a year and a half hot streak a la Bill Hall and Casey McGhee and everyone expected that was his norm.