Melvin does have a problem with the call ups. He knows he is in the minority, so He fights the unlimited roster by trying to get teams to have a set 30 players for each game. He believes that all season long teams play with a 25 man roster and it's absurd to have unlimited rosters. Basketball and football don't allow expanded rosters. I think his problem is now that he's in Milwaukee he has a budget to worry about and he can't afford to pay a bunch of guys to sit the bench for a month, get 1 ab a week, or pinch run. I do agree that it is silly that the roster size increases for the last month of the season. If anything, I think it should increase right after spring training since you have starters that can't go 7 innings yet and with rainouts you get multiple doubleheaders. I doubt theres a budget issue to worry about, its not like the september call ups are going to be earning big bucks or anything, its all a prorated amount, or 1/6th of the minimum salary of $507,500, or $85k for a full month, which some dont get. So they get a prorated amount of that prorated salary based on the number of days remaining in the season (which ends up being 34 going into October).