My thoughts, for what it's worth: Villar: .730 OPS, 1 WAR No. He isn't much of a fielder but playing at 2B should help vs his horrible numbers at 3B. He is a quality if not borderline elite lead off man, so 1 WAR seems nuts. Broxton: .682 OPS, 1 WAR. Maybe, the guy is all over the place from brutal to white hot. Braun: .837 OPS, 1.9 WAR. He would have to be hurt much of the year, so it's possible I guess Thames: .626 OPS, -1.8 WAR. Just a silly signing. Classic Stearns where he tries to get cute instead of taking a quality guy, but -1.8 suggests Yuni bad. I can't see that. Shaw: .741 OPS, 1.1 WAR. Seems spot on. Susac: .707 OPS, 0.9 WAR. Again seems pretty viable. He is a quality back up catcher but as a starter, replacement level seems appropriate Arcia: .666 OPS, 0.3 WAR this would be a disaster. I think he will turn out to be nice defensive SS who will be meh on offense but should steal some bases. This War suggests he won't play much and I think he will play a lot. Santana: .787 OPS, 0.9 WAR. Seeing how WAR really values corner OF D this is possible. I do think he will be a 800 to 850 OPS guy.