I think its quite easy to do so. That doesn't mean he did a good job or anything starting the way he did, but Reilly didn't do a good job either. He swung at ball 3, then hit a dribbler when he knew a FB was coming but got lucky it went to the right spot. The pitcher being generally good got it in there when he needed and throws upper 90s with movement on his FB and got the weak contact which is his job.
Its baseball, you can't win every game and sometime just a few feet one way or the other make a big difference. Crap happens some times. Bad D play on a dribbler, a walk, then another dribbler through the crack. It happens, didn't go your way today. Its not anything to make a big deal or sweeping judgments about.