I really don't think college is being overly pushed on kids and tech college certainly don't have a negative stigma. I recall going to the tech college at least 6 times before I graduated HS and never once did we ever visit the actual university close by. At the end of the day for the large majority of people college is the best path in life...that is just the reality and rightfully it is pushed. Trying to push being a plumber etc. is not going to work. Either you want to be that or you don't. We don't need people in trade schools that don't like it...that would be awful. That is probably what every garbage plumber, mechanic, electrician had happen. Most of the people in college that are failing, directionless, or wasting their time can be fit into like three groups: 1) Their parents are paying for them to be there thus reducing motivation etc. It also makes many of them totally not think about how financially advantageous their future major will be. That is where you get Sally doing women studies or painting pictures for four years. Now you could say this could include kids being there because they were pushed to by their parents. However, in my four years at college I never heard anyone say they went to college because their parents or their high school told them to. I really just don't think that is as common as some think. 2) They are getting lots of grant/free money to go. As with #1, motivation in college can get pretty spotty when someone else is footing most of the bill for you. I went to a school that had a large diverse background and admitted a lot of kids from struggling communities. Yes, the lack of cost allowed them to get in, but many just weren't that motivated to actually put in the effort. They probably didn't want to go to college anyway. Of course I would never say we should stop giving out grants, it is a double edged sword. Many waste them, but it also helps some make college possible. 3) The idea that you must go to college right away even if you have no idea what you want to go for, gap years are like the devil. The amount of people I saw never really figure out a major or it takes so long they end up with 5-6 years in college was really high. That expensive and many just didn't pick a great major in the end. They either picked something fun like art or did business management that they weren't passionate about. Which the later usually ends up causing them to not use it after graduation. Of course there is a valid reason why gap years are frowned upon. Statistically gap years end up lasting forever and kids never go. Of course maybe that is good and they shouldn't have gone in the first place. As far as the gen eds and all the 'unneeded' classes. I personally support having them, I think it is highly beneficial to a lot of students. It forces you to interact with different backgrounds and different ways of thinking. Of course for some they are trying to figure out their major taking those gen eds. I get to some people they don't need it and it is wasteful. They can't make 10,000+ different paths through college to please everyone. Some of those majors may not even exist if there aren't gen ed students to fill the classes to get money for that department. I am sure many never used to the gym they paid $150 a year for. I am sure many don't utilize the black student union that gets $250 from every student either. Those things are incredibly valuable to some though.