Hader/JJ are in the top 5 NL relievers in IP, JJ is 3rd among qualifying relievers in ERA (Hader is 15th with a 1.00 ERA, so lots of great relievers thus far). JJ falls way behind Hader in terms of K/9 and FIP/xFIP/DRA (very surprised that JJ's DRA is like 5-something). Similar to Travis Shaw last year, JJ deserves an AS game berth but there just might be too many talented relievers ahead of him. If 6 relievers make the AS game for the NL, right now I'd probably go with (not my choices but likely selections): 1. Josh Hader 2. Wade Davis (most saves with 11) 3. Brad Boxberger (2nd most saves with 10) 4. Jeurys Familia (3rd most saves with 9, ERA under 2) 5. Brandon Morrow (hasn't given up a run yet and throws heat) 6. Adam Ottavino (same numbers as JJ essentially but much higher K rate, much lower FIP/xFIP, roughly same number of IP, and his stuff is just off the charts nasty) Carl Edwards Jr is also doing what JJ has done in terms of numbers but with better peripherals and way more K's. The problem is once you open it up to non-closers, the options expand dramatically and there are a lot of good relievers out there. Watching JJ this year has been something special and his grit and determination isn't shown in the basic numbers, and I agree that he's absolutely worthy of being an All Star, but I just don't see it happening this year particularly with Hader already likely taking up a spot. Now if Knebel comes back and isn't as effective and JJ starts to get every save opportunity in the 9th and starts racking up saves? Then maybe, but that seems unlikely given how CC has run the bullpen thus far.