Hardy had a down year, but still has plenty of value, especially considering teams still trot guys like Betancourt, Punto, Cabrera, and the like out as an everyday SS. You can find plenty of guys just like JJ that have good career numbers, and took a dip in '09...that happens every season, take a look at career stats, and they are up and down. Cuddyer had a down '08, Hinske had a down '07, etc. Their value goes down a bit, but for the most part, they have enough of a track record to "lock in" a majority of their worth. Several GM's will even look to "buy low", as JJ will be cheaper than he was last year because of his down '09. I don't see any way the Crew keeps the guy making $5-6M when it is apparent Escobar is ready. Alcides won't hit a whole lot, but he'll slap the ball around and hopefully, improve as the campaign goes on. If Counsell, or another veteran is around to pick up some starts versus tough RHP, it will help set him a bit for success as well.