Ajay, many of those players are simply not very good. OXS was once again 98% accurate in predicting runs scored, so you can't lower that and still expect to score more runs. As I point out, but it does not seem to get discussed because it's not fun, OBP used to be undervalued, and now, it's all but impossible to find league average OBP available for anything but a high price, in both salary and trade cost. If you find cheap OBP, it's going to have warts. That's one reason Weeks still has oodles of value, even after "only" hitting his career norms...he gets on base, and when he does, he scores. And, let's not forget they were an above average offensive team. One decent 3B might make this an upper echelon offense...I believe PHIL was .007 higher in both OBP and SLG, and they were 2nd in runs scored. When a car has a flat tire, the easiest thing to do is change the tire. I'll save overhauling the engine for another time. EDIT: For example, Brosius had 200 AB's 9 times in his career, and he had a OBP of .307 or less 5 times. Adding an automatic out to the lineup won't do any good, even if he does occasionally hit a ground ball to 2B to advance a runner.