Put me down in the “no Braun” camp. I get the votes in favor of him, and he was my favorite Brewer growing up. And yes, one can make a very sound case that the real Mount Rushmore is a testament to the fact that greatness does not preclude moral controversy. But if I’m making the call, Braun is out. His decisions and behavior were an absolute outrage. I can’t even begin to comprehend how I would have made sense of the Brewers winning the title in 2011 and then the scandal tarnishing all of it. I very well might have given up on baseball after that. So to me, he is persona non grata.
So assuming we’re considering only players, and that Yount/Molly are up there in whatever order you like, and Braun is out in disgrace, I’d put Sabbathia on for his role in rescuing the team from obscurity through a transcendent run in 2008, the likes of which we will probably never see again. And Yelich holds the last spot for now owing to his contributions as a whole. He’s a bubble guy, but hoisting a trophy would pretty much cement him for me.