Well, from reading Haudricourt's blog posts, it sounds like the Brewers did everything they reasonably could to make something work out, despite the diabetes diagnosis. They had no way of knowing he had diabetes back in June, presumably. I am sure some will still find a way to blame Melvin for this, ignoring that the Brewers get an extra first round pick next season. Also, one other point to raise. I assume Covey is getting a full ride scholarship at San Diego. Yes, guaranteed money is one thing. But if he applies himself academically and graduates with a useful degree, he'll probably have connections to land a great job. Chances are he'll be able to earn much more than the $2 million he would have gotten from the Brewers; even without pitching a single inning of professional baseball. I think that makes his decision look a lot less "idiotic."