I think my biggest problem with Melvin is how indecisive he was on where the team was heading mid-season in '09. Yeah, we were still kind of competitive in June and July. He traded for Lopez, which I do think was a nice move. However, he did nothing to help the starting pitching at all. It was obvious that some key aces were available, but he let them go to other teams. Supposedly he was involved in negotiations, but he wasn't over aggressive. By the trading deadline it was obvious the team desperately needed SP help if we were going to make a legitimate push for the playoffs. Instead he essentially stood pat. Then in August when we could have dealt some veterans for perhaps at least some mid-level prospects or cheaper young guys, he didn't even bother to make a move then. I know hindsight is 20/20, but if he had dealt a few pieces like Hoffman, Counsell, Cameron, Kendall, maybe even Gamel and/or Salome, the team would probably be in much better shape today. Either your team is in it or isn't in it. You can't just make a couple middling moves and pretend you're trying to still compete.