The fact is JDLR didn't do anything special when he was a Brewer, and Cruz was basically blocked at the time. Neither were regarded as a stud prospect by that point. I'm sure a small minority were against their trades (Hey, Ben Hendrickson's dad screamed at me in a private chat that Cruz was the Brewers' best player at the time...maybe he was right???). People forget that the point of a trade isn't to try and completely fleece the other team. Such occurrences are pretty rare in MLB. Yes, they can happen, but it's usually due to a player getting hurt or just woefully under-performing. The best trades usually help all clubs involved. You have to give to get, as they say. Cruz and JDLR were both seen as fairly expendable at the time, hence why neither are no longer with the Brewers. I don't think it's anything to complain about in regards to Melvin, nearly five years after the fact. I agree with the assessment that if the team finishes under .500 this year, it's probably time to move on from Melvin. Sometimes a franchise just needs a change in direction.