Their career BA's are very similar, but Jenkins has struck out a LOT more, and Carlos has more HR's and RBI's. Carlos is clearly superior. Actually, no. Carlos: .283/.338/.492 .830 OPS Jenks: ..279/.347/.503/ .850 OPS So Carlos has more HR's, but Jenkins actually slugs better than him, and walks more per PA. Carlos only has 21 more HR in 437 more AB's, and has the additional RBI's you'd expect out of esentially playing one extra season. Jenkins is actually more productive than Carlos according to OPS. And for the record, in baseball reference under Carlos Lee, the player who is listed as most similar to Carlos all-time is Geoff Jenkins.