It's fine to look at 2013 and think there's a shot, but what's the plan for making that happen? For position players, I don't think they need to do a thing. They will need to figure out where Gamel fits in, if he does, and whether Hart is a 1B or a RF, but that's about it. They have a good lineup, and everyone there is returning, or can be brought back. The rotation is loaded with question marks. It's quite possible that Gallardo will be the only starter that began this year in the rotation, that will be returning. Fiers will be there, but then what? Estrada is probably a good #5, but nothing more. Then there's Peralta, Thornburg, and Rogers, all of which have potential, but are not sure things to be viable starters next year. It's fine if they want to go with some combination of those guys, but don't expect it to be a good, or even average rotation. They probably need at least one starter in free agency, and it has to be a very good one, not an "innings eater". I don't even know where they will start with the bullpen. More or less, it will need to be completely rebuilt, and it won't be as simple as going out and signing the best FA relievers that we can find. They were not contenders this year with Greinke and Marcum in the rotation most of the year. It's not a foregone conclusion that they can't be contenders without them, but it's going to take a very good offseason and then a lot of things going right. They're not a very good team right now with the talent that they have, and there's not a ton of reinforcements on the way coming up from the minors.