PCA overall because he's a generational defender at a key position but I would bet on Chourio's raw offensive numbers beating PCA over the remaining length of the contract.
This is the problem with playing matchups. If you flip a coin enough times you get heads like 5 times in a row and the result is benching a hot hitter for a week.
Not sure how much of this is Murphy...we know he has some control over batting order but in many cases the analytics are informing these decisions.
The Cubs were facing Eric Lauer today who won't sniff the Dodgers' postseason rotation. How did our 6-0 record against LA work out for us last postseason?
That said, the Cubs are probably one of the best 5 teams in MLB. Possibly one of the best 3.
We all did, they were ridiculously red hot in summer. Then the offense went cold later in September into October.
I'd rather have the hitting slump now. And this team can pitch way better than the 2025 team.
I agree that it’s a reasonable hypothesis but the sample of pitchers used is quite small (just 38 good and 38 bad). He doesn’t say what fraction of our total ABs are in his sample but it’s probably very small since we face 400+ pitchers per season.
A .270 wOBA against the top pitchers is also not terrible. It’s more that we absolutely destroy bad pitching while we are mediocre against very good pitching.
Last year around this time I remember we were discussion whether the offense was peaking too early. It turned out they were. I'm accepting of their slumping right now assuming they eventually snap out of it.
Arozarena was the only bat I would have wanted but he wasn't available and would have cost one of our top-10 prospects.
Last August.
He was doing 2-3 inning relief outings earlier this year but has been doing 1 inning lately in close games as he's proven himself in a higher leverage role.