I don't think that is what this team needs the most right now. Unless they complement the signing of someone like Looper with the signing of someone like Brian Fuentes, which would strengthen the entire pitching staff from the bottom up (instead of from the top down, which is how CC strengthened the team), I'm not a big fan of the team adding Looper as it stands by itself. I think this is the best post in the thread with regards to how I feel about this signing.... Looper is statistically very similar to Bush, and you already mentioned Suppan and McClung. Suppan given the $27M he is owed, will not get booted from the rotation. I think that this is an important point in this discussion... Unless Suppan is hurt, he is going to be a part of the rotation as long as he is a Brewer -- the Brewers may push him down to #5, but they aren't going to move Suppan out of the rotation unless they move him out of Milwaukee altogether. I don't see Looper as an upgrade from Bush -- perhaps McClung, but probably not a very substantial one. Of course this deal could give us some SP depth -- but I would rather see that depth come from adding to the top (or near the top) and sliding everyone down, rather than adding to the bottom. If this is a one year deal, or a 2 year deal for $11M, I like this signing a lot more... If we add an arm to the BP (like Patrick mentions Fuentes), then this makes a lot more sense as well. I guess to me, it all depends on how much money we spend. I just think Doug Melvin does a very solid job at managing a mid or small-market team, Even the bad Gagne deal was limited in risk at just one season. Jeff Suppan says hi! -- While I certainly, do not disagree that DM does a fine job overall, He has made some FA boners.