BIS actually shows Weeks as improving last year and to my observation it is correct, he made strides last year defensively for sure. He is still bad, and you cannot necessarily claim he is improving or making strides -- He may have made less errors, but that's going to naturally fluctuate from year to year, it is not as if he is going to do worse every year or exactly the same. Mota had a better year this year than he did last year, I don't think he improved though as a pitcher. Generally speaking fans judge a fielder on the first few games they watch involving him and then just remember the big blunders and great plays and the rest just passes by them. You keep saying this. I think it is about fine time you back it up with some stats. Generally speaking stat guys make arbitrary hand waving arguments about fans to discredit their observations, neglecting to realize that even in their admittedly general statement, it may be correct to a specific situation.