You could probably construct an intelligent argument supporting Tulowitzki for ROY. The offensive bar is much lower at SS than 3B for one. Second, even if Tulowitzki's defense is average for a SS, he has a clear edge over Braun. Last, When you are talking about ROY or MVP awards, counting stats do count, so Tulowitzki's advantage in that regard shouldn't be ignored. Do I think that's enough to justify picking Tulowitzki over Braun? Probably not, especially when you consider park factors. Of course, the author spent more time comparing their names than anything else, so.. wow... what an odd article.