In his minor league career, Olt averages a HR every 20 PAs, that number shrinks to a HR every 14.6 PAs in AA. Smoak has a career minor league ratio of a HR every 32.2 PAs, 37.8 in AA. I'm not saying its the end all be all of stats, but based on that, it seems like Olt has a bit more power than Smoak. Olt career OPS - .914, Smoak - .859. Smoak also only played 1B. Olt has played 1B/3B/RF (2 games) in his minor league career. Could he be Smoak part 2, sure, but the numbers say a different story.