Who will win the 2012 NL ROY?

[Invader3K]

Harper? Frazier? Miley? Fiers? Aoki? Who do you think, Brewers fans?

[torts]

Fiers doesnt have enough IP, I think it'll come down to Aoki and Harper, with Harper winning because the Nationals are in 1st place and he's been a pretty productive player for being 19.

[torts]

though, if the Brewers DO get close to or get in that last WC slot, and Aoki stays hot, it really could be a pretty close race... Aoki has won a couple games in the last few weeks on his own to help the Crew get in the position they are in

[BoxedWineWarrior]

It'll be Harper based on the national guys I follow on twitter. Frazier has gotten some love and rightfully so but Harper gets so many mentions, I'd be surprised if it isn't him.

[rluzinski]

Fiers doesnt have enough IP, I think it'll come down to Aoki and Harper, with Harper winning because the Nationals are in 1st place and he's been a pretty productive player for being 19.

 

Harper: .265/.337/.458

Aoki: .285/.352/.426

 

Very close there. Since Harper is younger and has played more at CF, I'd have to give him the nod as well, though.

[fondybrewfan]

I doubt most people outside of MIL even know who Aoki is so I am going to say he is a longshot regardless of where the Brewers finish up. It will be Miley or Harper most likely; whether they would deserve over Aoki is another story. Aoki's success has been under the radar

[1992casey]

I've added this topic to the Designated Threads List.

[jerichoholicninja]

I don't see how Harper can win. He'll get a lot of votes but his numbers aren't good enough. Wade Miley should win.